These boards are awesome. The Hall effects sensors work accurately from what I can see and have had no issues whatsoever even while playing fairly consistently for the last year or so. I believe this a solid solution to one half of the issue seen with joysticks. Soldering was easy as well as clean up. White boards look slick. Components fit perfectly into through hole pads and the board fits nice and snug in controller. Only thing I can say was the c stick board seems to have a bit of play when set in place but this isn't an issue when the controller is clammed together. The experience of selecting and pulling controller parts to solder on was some of the most fun Ive had with electronics in a while. Great learning experience for me.